Raster Reviews: every submisson for the Crossover Dubs
Jun 14, 2017 17:09:51 GMT
reallyawesomeguy117 likes this
Post by raster0fmandomness87 on Jun 14, 2017 17:09:51 GMT
alright so Mark Riquelme given the kind of person he is probably wants feedback on his submissons. but why stop there. let's look on every submission I got and see which ones were good and which ones were mostly there due to a need for new clips:
SuperIdiotMan00
Steven Universe/Shrek
great
Amazing World of Gumball/Blazing Saddles
rather weak joke and a bit "inside jokey" in the sense only those who saw the episode (I fortunately being one) knows what the cupcake was reading to them, but the way you recontextualized the audio was clever enough to pass
Team America: World Police/Blazing Saddles
pretty mediocre, only joke is that "rambling incoherent guy is giving a different rambling incoherent speech". no lie this probably woulda been rejected had I gotten more entires for #1
Rick and Morty/12 Oz. Mouse
good
Steven Universe/Hair
too long (again had there been more meat in #1 this probably woulda ben shortened) but you get major points for getting creative in terms of a dirty song to use. most in this situation woulda probably just used Niggerz Bop or Family Reunion
SpongeBob Movie/Simpsons
good
overall: 4/6, which would average to 3.5/5
Rockorangeedits
Ed Edd 'n Eddy/Tales from the Crypt/Sadus
album cover desperitly needed to be bigger, I didn't get the joke until a couple rewatches at first
Rageaholic/Hell's Kitchen
alright, not good but not reject-worthy
Napalm Death
good, but the text shoulda been featured as a slide rather than a quick blip
Bronson/Penn & Teller/Tenacious D
probably woulda been rejected if more entries were had for twoi
Spaceballs/Napalm Death
great
overall: 3.5/5
Mark Riquelme
Superheroines/asdfmovie7 #1
fucking awful. you didn't even have the characters be in a new location hence the JOKE of "let's take this outside" - (it turns out that was literal). this is not going to be in the final
Superheroines/asdfmovie7 #2
great
Superheroines/Sandstorm
alright, this will be accepted but only because of how scarce song-based entires are
Kelly Eden/SammyClassicSonicFan
bad. it coulda worked but you REALLY needed a better clip of someone angry (as well as maybe a funnier line of Sammy's). will be rejected too
Splatoon/Tropic Thunder
bit overused a sound but it was better than coolcat001100's version (funnier clip of an angry person)
overall: 2/5
if I were to give them standardized scores
SIM: B
Rocko: B-
Mark: D
Jman92854's will be added when the video is out, as they are private now, but I'll tell you this: he no joke got an A+
SuperIdiotMan00
Steven Universe/Shrek
great
Amazing World of Gumball/Blazing Saddles
rather weak joke and a bit "inside jokey" in the sense only those who saw the episode (I fortunately being one) knows what the cupcake was reading to them, but the way you recontextualized the audio was clever enough to pass
Team America: World Police/Blazing Saddles
pretty mediocre, only joke is that "rambling incoherent guy is giving a different rambling incoherent speech". no lie this probably woulda been rejected had I gotten more entires for #1
Rick and Morty/12 Oz. Mouse
good
Steven Universe/Hair
too long (again had there been more meat in #1 this probably woulda ben shortened) but you get major points for getting creative in terms of a dirty song to use. most in this situation woulda probably just used Niggerz Bop or Family Reunion
SpongeBob Movie/Simpsons
good
overall: 4/6, which would average to 3.5/5
Rockorangeedits
Ed Edd 'n Eddy/Tales from the Crypt/Sadus
album cover desperitly needed to be bigger, I didn't get the joke until a couple rewatches at first
Rageaholic/Hell's Kitchen
alright, not good but not reject-worthy
Napalm Death
good, but the text shoulda been featured as a slide rather than a quick blip
Bronson/Penn & Teller/Tenacious D
probably woulda been rejected if more entries were had for twoi
Spaceballs/Napalm Death
great
overall: 3.5/5
Mark Riquelme
Superheroines/asdfmovie7 #1
fucking awful. you didn't even have the characters be in a new location hence the JOKE of "let's take this outside" - (it turns out that was literal). this is not going to be in the final
Superheroines/asdfmovie7 #2
great
Superheroines/Sandstorm
alright, this will be accepted but only because of how scarce song-based entires are
Kelly Eden/SammyClassicSonicFan
bad. it coulda worked but you REALLY needed a better clip of someone angry (as well as maybe a funnier line of Sammy's). will be rejected too
Splatoon/Tropic Thunder
bit overused a sound but it was better than coolcat001100's version (funnier clip of an angry person)
overall: 2/5
if I were to give them standardized scores
SIM: B
Rocko: B-
Mark: D
Jman92854's will be added when the video is out, as they are private now, but I'll tell you this: he no joke got an A+